West LA Times

Lee Zeldin, a former New York congressman, has been appointed by President-elect Donald Trump to lead the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA). This decision has raised eyebrows among experts in environmental law, including Ann Carlson from UCLA. Carlson expressed concerns over the choice of Zeldin, stating that Trump's Cabinet picks prioritize loyalty over experience or expertise.

Carlson highlighted that Zeldin lacks any background with the EPA's regulated industries or its bureaucratic processes. "The oddest thing about Trump appointing Zeldin to oversee the EPA is that he doesn’t have any experience with the bureaucracy or the industries that the EPA regulates," she remarked. This approach contrasts with Trump's first administration, which saw appointments of individuals like a coal-industry lobbyist and a former attorney general who opposed strong environmental regulations.

Loyalty seems to be a primary factor in these appointments, according to Carlson. She noted, "As far as I can tell, anyone who has expressed any concern over any of Trump’s policies... are disqualified from serving." This could potentially limit the pool of talent available to advance Trump's agenda.

Rolling back climate regulations set by President Biden will require more than executive decisions; it involves legal processes under laws like the Clean Air Act. "You can’t just refuse to regulate," Carlson explained, emphasizing that following proper legal procedures is crucial.

Carlson also commented on Matt Gaetz's appointment as Attorney General, calling it "shocking" due to his lack of experience in practicing law and running organizations. The Department of Justice plays a significant role in defending administration policies and adopting legally sound rules.

Looking ahead, Carlson will be observing who fills sub-Cabinet positions at the EPA and other climate-related agencies such as Transportation and Energy departments. These roles require Senate confirmation and are essential for executing policy agendas effectively.

Ann Carlson serves as Shirley Shapiro Professor of Environmental Law at UCLA School of Law and is involved with setting federal fuel economy standards during her tenure with the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration under President Biden.